Last Resort: A Tribute To Mark Wolf 11/1/26 (Catch it on IWTV)
Eddie Kingston vs. Calvin Tankman
MD: I could write a real nice review of this one. I could. Would be easy. Would basically write itself like so many Eddie Kingston matches do.
I should. This was the main event of the tribute show to Mark Wolf, a show celebrating IWA-Mid South. IWA Mid-South. Big and earnest and messy and over the top, giving you too much and not enough, and more than you could ever want and more than you could ever handle and rough around the edges with the spirit of Indie Wrestling.
I think maybe that this review might be a little rough around the edges too.
It's 2026. Eddie Kingston is 44 years old. Do you know what happens when you turn 40? Most people reading this won't. Even if you're in decent shape, everything becomes a little harder. You kick one foot over the other when getting out of bed. You jam your foot under the opened car door to help propel you out. Little tricks, little things. They help you move with the same speed and force that you used to. Some of it is just muscle memory, learning the best, most efficient way to do things.
Eddie had a horrific injury. A career ender maybe. And he came back from it. He's not the Eddie Kingston of 2010 or 2016 or 2021. He's not the Continental Crown winner. He's not. What? Am I going to lie about that? Yeah, we'll get that to lying bit in a minute. It's important.
But he's still Eddie Kingston.
There are so many different stories that we, as human beings, can explore in our art. Pro wrestling can tell so many stories. We've optimized a star rating system around the idea of "workrate." If you look back at the critical thought of the last 40 years, it's workrate that drives the discussion.
How much motion? How much action? How many moves? How hot was the finishing stretch? How much did they pop the crowd? It clearly drives the Observer star ratings and it even anchored the DVDVR week to week reviews. They were Workrate reviews, in name if not in principle. That was the counterculture to the counterculture and it was there too.
No wonder we've landed where we have.
And where we've landed is a world where there's no room for 2026 Eddie Kingston. Not in conventional wrestling criticism.
"Fat, slow, out of shape, over the hill, broken down, unbelievable, Japanese cosplaying, impossible to work with, stubborn Eddie Kingston. He lacks "polish." Doesn't pass the airport test. No one wants to see a bum off the street."
That's what they see. That's what they claim. And if you were to go on about what makes Eddie great, to go on about what makes his matches special, and I am about to do that right now... they won't attack you on the points.
They will attack you on your intention. On how genuine you are. Best case? They'll say you're lying to yourself. Worst case? They'll say you're lying to everyone else.
And why is that? You ask me, and if you're reading this, then you're asking me. No one's making you. If you ask me, it's because they lack something. It's not a difference of opinion. It's an affliction. It's how they were conditioned. How they were raised as pro wrestling fans. How they exist in a society. What their incentives are. Their own insecurities. Those poor bastards.
So they think I'm a liar acting in bad faith and I think they're stunted and broken and lacking, and as such, they imagine anyone with an opinion they can't understand not as a starting point to grow and something new and wonderful to discover, but as a bad faith challenge to dogma and norms and the status quo, a status quo they find preferable and safe and secure.
Thankfully, however, even though I am swiping at them, I am not actually talking to them.
I am talking to you, a reader (on paragraph 17 or what not) with curiosity still in your heart. I am going to paint a picture here, what I saw in watching this match, what I felt.
Did I meet it halfway? No, I didn't have to. Did I meet it a quarter of the way? Good question. Maybe. Maybe I did. Did I do that out of bad faith? Did I do it to get clout? Did I do it for all the wrong reasons? I really don't think so. I think I did it because what I saw was worth taking a leap on, because I wanted to embrace it, and because to me, at this stage of my life, it was so damn easy to embrace.
So.
Eddie Kingston. With at least some of the flaws and faults listed above, sure.
Calvin Tankman.
So many stories we can tell. Some of them are about decline. Some of them are about aging. Some of them are about being lost in the wilderness of middle age, of trying to figure out what it's all worth, of why you still do it. There's value in that.
What happens when you spent your whole life loving wrestling, when it saved you, gave you everything, but also took so much away? What happens when you can no longer be the agitator pushing up against those who came before you but are now the one being pushed up against? What happens when everything which was so easy before is now a struggle?
That's interesting! That's compelling! You see so much of that in so many other forms of literature. In movies and plays and novels. It's human as hell.
Pro wrestling is a narrative medium where two people push against one another using violence and technique, all held together by training and heart and sheer will. It's a game of human chess, and sometimes it can be more interesting when the chess pieces are dingy and chipped than if everything is sleek and perfect and shiny.
If you look at Eddie Kingston's defining feuds of this decade, they were with peers, yes, but more than that, they were with people who were a few steps before him: Punk, Danielson, and to a degree, Claudio. They were about those people not seeing something in him, about those people leaving when he and everyone around them maybe needed them most. He had to find his own way through the darkness without them. They left him nothing but their own biased and harsh judgments.
With Tankman, the roles were reversed. He was the one left behind. Eddie was the one questioning him, doubting him.
That's compelling as hell.
The match starts with Eddie dancing around, cocky, playful, refusing to take this serious, or at least seeming as such. They lock up. They break clean. Eddie teases a cheapshot; no, he thinks about it. That's interesting. What's going on there? Is he holding back out of hidden regard for Tankman? Is he actually worried despite the bluster? Does he think he needs it? Has he grown past it? What's going on in his head?
Also compelling as hell.
They break clean in the corner. Tankman claims to the world "No one's afraid of you Eddie."
Interesting claim, isn't it? Why that? Why then? There's dissonance at play. Tankman towers over Eddie. He's younger, faster, stronger, AND bigger. He has more to prove. He has more places to go. Eddie should be afraid of him.
But Tankman establishes as the starting point that people are supposed to be afraid of Eddie, that Eddie is considered someone to be afraid of, that Tankman, who towers over Eddie, should be afraid. That maybe he once was. (That maybe despite what he just said, maybe he should still be).
In framing it that way, in ceding that ground to Eddie, he gave him power, even as he claimed otherwise.
And that is compelling as hell too.
So, they haven't even done anything yet. They've just locked up. Eddie teased a punch. Tankman made a claim. And there's just so much to dig into here. We're as far away from conventional workrate as possible.
We're also very far away from Sports Entertainment. This isn't some sort of navel-gazing self-referential bullshit. No one's pointing at a sign. No one's talking about entertaining people and putting smiles on faces or the WWE Universe. This is personal. Hurt feelings. Hard roads. The ghosts of the past and the realities of the present.
Early on, they trade shots, they eat shots. Tankman has more behind his but Eddie keeps coming. He tries for an exploder off the ropes. It's not a good idea, especially not this early. But he's not yet fighting against Tankman. He's fighting his own limitations. He'd told him it'd be an easy night.
Unsurprisingly, Tankman takes over. Wrestling isn’t math but sometimes it is. Size, youth, strength, more to prove to the world. Tankman revels in it, leaning on Eddie, trash talking him, shutting him up and loving every moment of it.
And what we get is a sort of conventional structure. We have what looks to be a babyface working from underneath against a larger heel, with fiery hope spots and massive cutoffs.
But Tankman isn’t a conventional heel. He has a point. Maybe on paper, he’s the one that we should be rooting for. Maybe Eddie is that much of a monster, that much of a threat, that much of a boogeyman? Maybe Tankman’s enjoying this a little too much, reveling in it a little too much, but who could blame him? Still, those cutoffs? They’re huge. They’re babyface cutoffs really, a larger than life cross body block, a wild dive into the chairs (leaving Eddie next to a couple of Styrofoam concession containers, which is a weirdly perfect image post-dive).
And Eddie, even though he has the crowd behind him, because it’s hard not for him to have the crowd behind him, isn’t a conventional babyface here. You’re rooting for him, sure, but maybe not rooting for him to beat Tankman. You’re rooting for him to get his shit together. You’re rooting for him to stop taking Tankman lightly. You’re rooting for him to clean up his act, to find some way to get past all this, to lean on other people, to listen when you chant his name, to accept that he’s not alone in this world and that it matters. And step one of that is to get back on his feet and fire back against Tankman.
You can see all of this play out on Tankman’s face, see it play out on Eddie’s.
What critical language do we even have to discuss this? “Eddie worked well from underneath. He sold the leg well. Tankman kept things moving. His power moves looked impactful.” None of that cuts it. None of it.
What happened is that Eddie endured. He didn’t quit. For one more night, driven by pride, reminded by those chants, maybe even inspired by the fight Tankman brought to him, he kept getting up, kept kicking out, kept loving wrestling and let wrestling love him.
He finally got Tankman over. It wasn’t an exploder, more like a waterwheel drop, but it was impressive as hell. He threw the Kobashi chops. He dropped the strap and went for the Urakens. Tankman didn’t make it easy. Nothing seemed easy. Everything looked like a struggle. At one point towards the end, they were trudging through mud and time seemed to stop between blows.
And yeah, maybe, just maybe, that’s the moment where I leaned in a bit myself, just that 25% where I had to meet them, because given the story, given the truth that they were portraying, the very human truth, I found it worth it. Maybe I did it without thinking. Maybe I just felt. Maybe I felt something worth feeling. Maybe I took a breath and let go and stopped worrying about things like “execution” and left my own decades of having “workrate” ingrained in my head fall to the wayside like I have gotten so good at doing these last few years.
They were working hard. Clearly. They were rolling boulders up mountains and there was pathos and drama to every push. What good is a word if it can’t encapsulate its own literal meaning?
Pro wrestling is about minimizing the gap between seeing and feeling. And yeah, sometimes that means everything happening is crisp and clear and as fast as possible, to make it all look easy for the wrestlers, like they are gods and not men. But sometimes, it means making things feel as hard as they actually are, even harder. And there is room for both in pro wrestling. And there are stories that can be told with both.
Tankman had more to prove, but Eddie? Eddie literally can’t stop. He’s a shark. He’s an older shark, a beat up shark, even a depressed shark maybe, a sad shark, but he’s still a shark, and if he stops, that’s it. If he stops, he doesn’t start again, so he can’t stop.
He can’t stop and he kept swinging and he hit the DDT and won, and he gave Tankman his respect and he talked about Mark Wolf and IWA and all the people he lost and he told us all to hug the people we love and I don’t want to write this paragraph anymore, so I’m going to stop it and bring this thing to a close.
There are people who are going to read this review and point and laugh. Ivory towers (trust me, a pro wrestling discord is not an ivory anything, nor is it a tower). And they can. That’s the prerogative. Me? I’m going to pity those people. That’s mine.
I don’t want you, reading this, to do either, not to laugh or to pity. I want you to be past all that. We do it so you don't have to. You can do something better. You can be something better. I want you to go and watch this match, and at least try to feel some of the things I felt here, to let yourself go and give in and watch their faces and feel the weight of life and human emotion that they are dragging behind them, to be impressed that they somehow made it to the end despite all that.
No, look, I don’t even want you to feel the same things I was feeling, but to figure out how it makes you feel instead. If we agree, great. If not, that’s great too. But I want you to open yourself up to that, and celebrate the possibilities of pro wrestling. Don’t let yourself put everything in one tiny box or another. Celebrate that this match happened. Explore the possibilities of the person, and people, and company that it was remembering, the entire messy, ugly, insane tradition of indie wrestling, raw and human, and ridiculous and deranged and beautiful.
Because it’s all right there on the mat or at the VFW hall or Rec Center or Flea Market or just on your screen. When it’s worth it, when it’s really worth it, you just have to let go and meet it where it is.
Labels: Calvin Tankman, Eddie Kingston, IWA Mid-South
Read more!