AEW Five Fingers of Death 5/11 - 5/17 Part 3

AEW Supercard of Honor 5/15/26

Survival of the Fittest: Athena vs Billie Starkz vs Maya World vs Yuka Sakazaki vs Trish Adora vs Zayda Steel

Chapter 1: Zayda Steel

When opportunity knocks, Zayda Steel answers the door. She bet on herself, left the possibility of artificial glitz and glamour to rekindle her love for Pro Wrestling and start back at the bottom. Hard work is rewarded and she found herself under Christopher Daniels' tutelage. She lost a proving ground match to Athena back in April but found herself with a second chance, defeating Hyan to take the injured Persephone's spot in Survival of the Fittest. 

The match itself began with Athena and Billie at odds, Billie not wanting to tow the line. After a bit of shoving, Athena dragged Billie out to the floor by her hair to try to get her back on the right page, her page. Zayda saw opportunity knocking once again and she, Maya, and Trish surrounded the two of them. Athena tossed Billie into Zayda and ducked Maya and Trish's blows. 

Later on, opportunity would present itself again. Athena had survived the onslaught of Maya, Yuka, and Trish and was standing dominant in the ring. Zayda, throwing caution to the wind, slipped in with a chair and tossed it right at the champion's face. With some effort she lodged it in the corner. Maybe it took her just a bit too long, as Athena was able to reverse the subsequent corner whip. Zayda crashed hard and Athena pinned her, feet on the ropes. There would be other opportunities, other days, and Zayda would be there, ready and waiting.

Chapter 2 - Trish Adora

Trish Adora made her own opportunities. After crashing into Maya when Athena ducked, she sat out, watching Billie and Yuka criss-cross and rope-run against Athena and Billie. She asserted herself when the moment was right, chip on her shoulder, power coursing through her, and took out Billie and Zayda with a double spear. 

After Zayda was eliminated, Athena tried to continue on with the chair on Yuka. Maya may have been the one to come in with a Kendo Stick to break it up, but it was Trish who snatched it from her and flexed and stretched with it, beating Maya first with the stick and then with a chair. 

While she was busy with Maya and Billie was fighting with Yuka, Athena set up a lego set of chairs on the floor. Satisfied with her construction and feeling far more animosity towards Maya than Trish, Athena suggested a fortuitous alliance, Athena and Trish leaning down hard on Maya. But Athena doesn't have allies, she has minions, and Trish Adora is no one's minion. Refusing to let Athena berate her on the apron, Trish fired off on the champion and chokeslammed her through her own chair tower. 

Billie, initially at a loss, became enraged and targeted Trish. She had set up a table and had been working to put Yuka through it, but now she turned her all of her attention to hefting Trish up onto the announce desk and putting her through the other table. Trish fought her off, smashing Billie with a Death Valley Driver onto an announce desk that did, much like Trish herself, simply did not break. 

Back in the ring, Trish went for the kill on Yuka, throwing the Lariat Tubman at her. Yuka ducked and it hit a stumbling, still recovering Athena with the lariat instead. Trish went to capitalize but Yuka caught her with the Merry-Go-Round and pinned her. Trish had been a force in the match. She had the champion beat and it was only due to an interloper that she didn't have her pinned and eliminated too. There's more on the bone there. Athena needs challengers, and Trish, like always, has a point to prove and the strength, skill, attitude, and wherewithal to back it up.

Chapter 3 - Yuka Sakazaki

Yuka drifted through the match, the smile on her face tempered by a grit of her teeth. When everyone surrounded Athena early, it was Yuka who picked her moment and came off the apron to actually get her. She fought evenly against both Athena and Billie as the match went on. After Billie failed to put Trish through the table, Yuka successfully managed to put Athena through it, not just insult to injury after getting chokeslammed into the chairs, but injury to injury as well. 

When Trish hit the Lariat Tubman on Athena, Yuka could have hung back and let Athena get eliminated from the match, ensuring a new champion, but that's not how Yuka operates. She meets the challenge before her. She is a creature of action and motion, of life itself. Athena had tossed a trash can into the ring and despite Athena pleading and begging Yuka not to do it, Yuka struck true. Yuka may be good natured, but she wasn't about to have the wool pulled over her eyes. Instead, she took trashcan in hand and maneuvered to the apron, hitting her magical girl splash with the can. Again, Athena was saved, this time by Billie.

Thus ambushed, her moment lost, Yuka quickly fell to Billie's Avalanche Starfall cradle facebuster. But as she went to the back, she knew that she had the champ all but beaten and that she could hold her head high.

Chapter 4 - Billie Starkz

Which brings us back again to Billie. Billie, Billie, Billie. Twice rebelled against Athena, twice defeated. Inaugural TV champion, lost the belt. Made it to the finals for the inaugural Pure champion, lost. 22 years old and woefully lost. A new college graduate, but forever a MIT Student. 

Her defiance here was feckless and quickly subsumed. Her fire? It came and went. She fought hard against Yuka, only to get swept under and choked in the ropes. She was infuriated by Trish's action and went right at her, only to be dropped onto the announce desk with a Death Valley Driver. She saved Athena with a chair, but those chair shots seemed to lack a certain amount of heart. 

After eliminating Yuka, it was now two-on-one against Maya. Athena was hurting so maybe Maya had a chance, but Billie was able to come out on top in their exchange with a Destroyer. That meant when Athena did make it back into the ring, two kendo sticks in hand, things looked very bad indeed for Maya. Athena tossed one to Billie, dark master to apprentice. But where Billie's heart is clouded, Maya's is pure, and she fought back, right to the point where she was jousting with Billie on the top, chairs draped upon the mat beneath them. Athena went to strike Maya. Maya moved. Billie got cracked and then crushed with a powerbomb off the top. 

Maybe there's a light off in the distance. Maybe there's a path towards it. But for Billie Starkz, it seems so very far off.

Chapter 5 - Maya World

This left Athena and Maya. While she is, in her own way, an apprentice to Athena, Maya's never been a minion. Instead, she's become the possible heir apparent that Billie no longer is, the Final Girl who might be able to not just survive the horror story that is Athena, but to be the one to actually end it. If Billie is looking for a light, Maya glows all on her own, a light to combat Athena's darkness.

But she wasn't going to be able to defeat it here, not in a match like this. Up until this point, the threat to Athena had been the numbers, the unpredictability. There could well be a final encounter between Athena and an ascendant Maya, but not on this night and not in this way. 

That's not to say she didn't account extremely well for herself. She did. She turned the tide very quickly. Athena had used every weapon imaginable (save maybe for the ladder that she and Billie had set up in the ring), leaving her just her own precious belt left. Maya ducked it and took over with a nasty DDT on the apron. She hit her Reinera slam but couldn't put Athena away. Then she went for the ankle lock. 

Athena can sometime be craven, can often be underhanded, but she was no quitter. Billie, holding a white towel, on the other hand, is prone to being overcome by emotion, and she had so much to feel here: the sting of defeat and disappointment, the further sting of her defiance once again deferred, her honest care and affection towards Athena, no matter how she treated her. Put all those together, and she had every reason to throw in the towel. Athena wouldn't let her though, not just stopping her but altogether dragging Billie into the ring.

That was the distraction Athena needed, and one giant O-Face from the top of the ladder later, Maya, her own brightness temporarily extinguished, was staring up at the lights, and Athena had survived another day.

Chapter 6 - Athena

Diamante rushed out to help Athena celebrate. They browbeat Billie, though not with any real malice or seriousness. As things stood, it was all well past the point of that. For the most part, Billie had come through. 

More than that, through hook and crook, Athena had come through. She had defended her kingdom, had stood strong in the face of maybe her greatest challenge. The numbers were against her, and yes, at times she hid behind Billie, but at others, she faced three people down at once, running from corner to corner to inflict damage and pounding her chest in victory after the fact. 

That led to her getting a chair thrown at her face by Zayda, of course, and in truth, she had terrible luck (hubris?) with the weapons in the match. Every time she tried to escalate, furiously kicking the set-up chair out of the corner to use it as a weapon (that organic, alive element of unpredictability that Athena brings to her matches that almost no one else in wrestling can match), setting up the chair tower, the table (well, that was Billie who set it up), bringing in the trash can, trying to use the belt... it all backfired on her. She survived, but only because Yuka saved her once and Billie the second time. 

Were she just a queen, she might fall to circumstance like this: a plot, a conspiracy, the odds being against her, but she's more than that. She's the forever champion, the fallen goddess. Someday she will fall, someday she must, and yes, her own hubris might be a large part of it, but it will have to be both epic, and this war was epic, and personal and intimate, in all the ways that this was not. 

As a match, it was smartly put together, mostly solved the multi-person problem of people just laying around (in part, by eliminating Zayda relatively early so that the numbers were off and Athena could either be convalescing or setting up contraptions to be used later), and was extremely character driven. 

As a story, it call came together fairly well, leaving much on the table in the best way. Yuka, Maya, and especially Trish all have a claim for the future. Billie's tension percolates all the more as she desperately grasps at light now even further beyond her grasp. 

As a defense, it is another giant notch upon the largest belt in wrestling, as Athena shakes the dust of her peers off and marches ever towards the greatest legacies still left before her. 

Read more!

AEW Five Fingers of Death (and Friends) 1/6 - 1/12

AEW Collision 1/11/25

Daniel Garcia vs. Katsuyori Shibata

MD: My favorite part of the entire WrestleDynasty card was watching Shibata and Tanahashi lock up. I'm not a big 2010s NJPW guy so I don't have a lot of nostalgia for the specific pairing but I am a big 1980s NJPW guy and it had the same sense of Inoki struggling for a grueling, tortured minute against every inch of a hold. Wrestling is the very best when the wrestlers put so much effort and care into even the smallest of things; if they care, the crowd will care. I certainly did.

Unfortunately, Garcia and Shibata couldn't start with that same sort of lock-up. This goes back to a tricky pothole that we all often fall into with match reviews. A match doesn't exist just for your star rating, to be reviewed and written up. It's part of a nexus of a show, of multiple shows, of the history of a promotion. That grueling lock up? It was needed far, far more for Jericho vs Dax at the end of the night. They needed all the help they could get and complex spots weren't going to cut it. Starting off with that wild intensity as they spilled out of the ring and jockeyed for position? That they could (and did) do.

Tanahashi and Shibata followed the lock up with chops, neither moving, just endless fighting spirit hard shots and that didn't do a single thing for me. They looked tough but there was no cause and effect, just endless cause for no effect until the time was up. Once it was up, it was too late.

Garcia and Shibata went right to chops as well, but it was an entirely different world. Remember, the last time they faced was for the Pure Title and Shibata in so many ways ate Garcia up. He was just crushing people during that run and despite Garcia coming in with bluster as the champ, he didn't have a chance. Here, a more seasoned, elevated Garcia stood tall, but got knocked down. He took the chops like they came out of a shotgun and then got back to his feet and fired back only for Shibata to eat them like they were nothing.

But Garcia kept getting up. He fell down. He got up. He fired back. It didn't work. He fell down. He got up. He fired back. That's a babyface. That's someone the crowd can get behind. That means so much more than even someone like Eddie Kingston, a folk hero in his own right, standing tall and going even with Shibata. That's admirable sure, but it's not heroic. It's not brave. It's mythic, but it's not relatable. Eddie doesn't need us to root for him. It's fine if we do, but he doesn't need us. Garcia does. And that changes everything.

Which meant there came a moment mid match where Garcia who had took shots and took shots and took some more finally found strength within him through channeled the crowd to stand tall and drive Shibata back. Because he had given so much early and because Shibata had given nothing at all, this mattered so much more than guys just shooting bombs at each other trying to impress with sheer quantity alone. This didn't overwhelm. It inspired.

Chops aren't the only part of Shibata's game though. Down the stretch, Garcia locked in the Dragontamer out of nowhere. Shibata is all technique, all struggle, yet he seemed to just let it happen. Once locked in, he calmly pushed himself up and flipped Garcia over into a leghold and then the figure-four leglock. Garcia, selling huge, struggled to make it to the ropes. That's not Inoki but instead Fujiwara, that sense of defensive wrestling, of gamesmanship where he's luring a trap for his opponent. You almost never see it in wrestling today so to watch it play out so beautifully is worth noting.

As is Garcia's Bret Hart-ian (and Darby Allin-ian) ability to snatch victory out of nowhere. Watching Cope vs Bill to start the night, I thought to myself that the spot where Bill hit his head on the exposed turnbuckle and then Cope somehow hit him with a huge power bomb would have been a perfectly fine finish. They instead went around a couple of rotations with some big kickouts (including of the spear) until they did the bit where Cope emulated Moxley (on commentary, Tony picked up on it but didn't go far enough with the idea that you become the monster you're fighting). Maybe the match needed that. Maybe it could have been in the post-match too. But that was such a memorable spot that it would have been even more memorable if it ended the match and it would help further that feeling that a match really could end at any point. AEW matches almost always use those moments for a big kickout and only end matches on set finishers after multiple rotations to get there. We'd be in a much more interested world of matches could end a minute or two earlier on a big, unexpected move.

Garcia's so good at finishing a match with the jackknife now, that I actually buy some of his other roll ups. Garcia's confidence to be vulnerable (with the chops, with having to pull himself to the ropes in the figure-four, with letting himself win with roll-ups out of nowhere instead of a dominant finisher) is a strength. It means the fans feel concern for him in the moment and then share in his triumph when he overcomes an opponent. It means his opponents look strong in defeat and feel like truly meaningful entities to defeat. It's babyface wrestling 101 but so few people over the last decade have dared to do it with open and earnest hearts and it makes Garcia stand out even more week after week.

ROH 1/09/25

Trish Adora vs. Harley Cameron

MD: First and foremost, this was a very good effort. Technically, this was Harley's first or second real babyface match and she only has so many matches under her belt in general. She had good energy. She tried to get the crowd into it. She sold sympathetically. She had a good comeback. All good things. Past the handshake right at the start and one shout in the middle, though, I didn't really see enough of what made her stand out over the last few months. 

In fact, Trish came off like the star here, not just basing like a champ (maybe even too good at times), hitting some standout strength spots (a few killer suplexes including two very different Germans), playing to the crowd and the camera and almost just riding the wave of the crowd like it was music at times. 

That's the sort of thing I've come to expect from Harley more. It's tricky. What was getting Harley over were the antics, but there has to be some real worry that without channeling some traditional babyface techniques, she's not going to stay over as a face and get the crowd behind her; she'll just bewilder them. I don't think that's the case. I want Garcia to go fully into those tropes. With Harley, I think she can be more Looney Tunes or Marx Brothers (or Bugsy McGraw or Les Kellett). She can confuse and frustrate her opponent with a sort of mad surrealism and still get swatted down and come back. 

It's a tricky balance. The first time she goes with the Wrath of Harley Cameron, it's funny. When she thinks it's a thing and it's not, that's funny. When it becomes a thing and it's in her tron, then it loses a bit of its appeal. It should come when you least expect it and maybe even when it's least appropriate.  I always thought that the weakest part of her act was coming out to the Outcasts music to the same choreographed moves. She should be interacting with the crowd and the camera on the way down, maybe starting to do some of those moves and getting distracted by the first shiny thing she sees and then try to go back to them and forgetting her place. Something like that. The spontaneity is the key with her. You tune into a Harley Cameron match because you know you're going to see something unexpected and it won't be the same the next time around. If you miss a Harley Cameron match you're going to miss something unique forever. That's the appeal. 

Ritual and meeting expectations are good. But for Harley, the expectation is the unexpected. That would be difficult for a ten year vet, let alone a 50 match rookie, but that's the position she's talented her way into. Big task, huge opportunity. But this (and the Mariah match) wasn't it.

Read more!

Matches from Beyond Wrestling Uncharted Territory 36 11/4/21

Masha Slamovich vs. Davienne

ER: This was a 6 minute pre-show showcase match, and it worked as advertised. I'm not sure I've ever watched a Masha Slamovich match before, and I'm sure that I've skipped past her matches on shows before. I assume I wrote her off due to her name sounding too Chikara Gimmick and never thought about it again. Now that I've seen her in a showcase match, I would like to seek out potential great matches, because I thought she came off great. This was 6 minutes, and this was a fairly breathless 6 minutes. Neither took a single breather and this was just wave after wave of some stiff shots and big kicks and a go go go pace. Davienne has nice selling, can get some nice force behind her clubbing shots, and went back to a flat boot yakuza kick that I liked. But Slamovich worked with a ton of intensity and really went for the kill on strikes. She had a solebutt that was like a young Naoki Sano, a couple of spinning heel kicks where she really used her heel as the blunt object and not just the side of her leg, and a lariat so much stronger than you'd expect from her frame. She packs a wallop and it made me want more Masha. Luckily she's wrestled practically as much as any human on the planet in 2021 so I have some options. 

37. Slade vs. Alec Price

PAS: Slade is pretty much a must watch wrestler for me at this point. I am not sure why he isn't booked in GCW or ICW-NHB as he is the most compelling guy to be doing that kind of new age ECW brawling. I hadn't heard of Price before, but thought he was great too. He has a real Harmony Korine vibe to him, a real scuzz who is great at making the crowd want to see him murdered. He takes a Wrestling Slade level beating, but actually is super vicious on offense too. Price gets mauled for a bit including getting lawn darted into the ringpost, but takes over by driving the top of a steel chair right into the top of Slade's kneecap and unleashes some sick looking leg work including one of the cooler dragon screws I have seen. The knee gives him an opening not to get steamrolled by Slade, and Price actually goes over by kneeing Slade hard in the balls and rolling him up in the ropes using the no DQ stip to steal one. Feels like a big rematch is coming, and Price is a new guy I am into.

ER: I agree, Slade is can't miss right now. He's the most NWA-Wildside vibe we've gotten out of a new wrestler in ages, a guy who feels more like a cult MMA star from UFC3 than a pro wrestler. It's testament to how good Alec Price was here that he managed to outshine Slade at times and come off credible against a guy I thought was going to tear him apart. Price looks like Jardi Frantz but wrestles more like Jimmy Jacobs or Brian Kendrick, which is a style I love. His pre-match mic work showed impressive timing and confidence, the kind of thing MJF wants to do every week but goes so long that it loses all momentum. Price made me a fan in just one minute, snatching the mic to say that this is his fed and he doesn't need to wrestle anyone in a No DQ match, delivering his demands with the right amount of venom and indignance. By the time Price clonked Slade with the mic I was sold, and when his strikes landed just as hard as Slade's I was through the roof. 

This looked like a bratty college Freshman somehow holding his own against a hardened convict and that's a vibe we don't get enough in wrestling. He stood up to a Slade beating and fought back by crossing Slade up, throwing hard stomach kicks and insanely taking a fight to a very dangerous man. His leg work was really vicious, dropping Slade patella first on a chair and throwing a Maeda-level dragon screw. The chose their chair spots really well, making them stand out as uniquely violent. Slade getting dropped on his knee looked even more painful than Price taking a disgusting snap suplex across two chairs on the floor, and that's because they went out of their way to make everything look vicious. Price pulling out the win felt like a huge shock, and he's so great at being able to fully piss off every person he wrestles. The Slade/Dickinson/Price 3 way feud could yield some memorable beatings, and this just made me want more.  

Matt Makowski vs. Tracy Williams

PAS: Williams had been in ROH for the last couple of years and off my radar, but it was good to see him back and working a very Catch Point style match against Makowski, who may be the best of that next generation of Catch Point inspired guys. Lots of very cool grappling, as you would expect. Williams put on an Octopus hold and when Makowski got the break he rolled it into a Fuller leglock. There was also some nice violent arm work from Makowski. Really appreciated how Williams would adjust his body in submission holds to lessen their effect, for example Makowski put on a cloverleaf and Williams rolled onto his side so he couldn't fully crank the back. Finish had a slap fight which I thought didn't look great, although I liked Makowski sneaking in a thumb to the eye to stun Williams enough for Makowski to sink in a sick looking choke and give him a nap. 

ER: I really like these two and like a lot of what they did to each other, but a lot of it felt a but more time-filling than match-building to me. There was some strong shootstyle wrestling, with some cool grappling fakeouts and mistimed striking, and all of it looked good but never felt like it built to what it could have. Still, there was a lot to like about this, because a lot of it was them doing their very cool thing. Makowski has some of the best strike exchanges in modern wrestling, sneaking in kicks in cool ways and excelling at catching strikes. Williams is able to work a strong mirror to Makowski's heavier onslaught, and I even thought the slap fight worked really well. I thought it looked like some of the better UWFI standing battles and not something that kept to a turn based system. This was two guys throwing open hands to face and body and I thought looked good, with the Makowski thumb a great climax to it. The submission work looked good, the striking looked good, it just felt less than the execution.  

Trish Adora vs. Jordan Blade

PAS: This is a pair of the DMV's finest fighting for Adora's Pan Afrikan World Diaspora Championship. This is my first time seeing Adora, but I have been a fan of Blade from her PPW UWFI rules stuff. I really liked how this started, with hard aggressive simple mat wrestling. Blade is a powerlifting champion and does a really great job at making her grappling feel weighty. Adora is able to whip down Blade's arm and then really goes to work on that, forcing Blade to do some throws with only one arm which was super impressive. Sadly I think they lost the thread a bit near the second half of the match. It got very Garganoish, lots of faces of despair on two counts and talking to hands, and the finish run was a lot of 2 count nearfall stuff. Adora has a signature "Lariat Tubman", and she did a short arm version of it for the win, and it didn't land the way I want a finishing lariat to land. Still there were lots of this match I liked and both wrestlers feel like they have a lot of promise. 

2021 MOTY MASTER LIST

Read more!