AEW Five Fingers of Death (and Friends) 11/9 - 11/15
AEW Full Gear 11/14/26
Mercedes Mone vs Marina Shafir
Polish
Look at that pernicious word, just hanging out there, owning that line.
It looks harmless. Benign. Reasonable, even. But trust me, no six letters could possibly be a more dismissive, patronizing force when discussing women's wrestling.
You hear about a "tax." Well, there it is.
Things don't hit clean. Things aren't taken clean. Things look collaborative. You can see the air. You can see the strings. They're just concentrating on making it to their next spot.
"They tried hard and the match was good, but things lacked polish."
These are things which are often excused or even seen as potential positives given some male wrestlers. Being rough around the edges can be engaging and exciting.
But those excuses almost never are allowed with women.
I would be very surprised if we don't see that word come up in the next week (maybe on Friday; Friday seems likely).
I know I talk about this a lot from different angles, but here it is again from another one. Pro wrestling commentary lost its way somewhere down the line. It probably never actually had its way in the first place.
Execution (and yes, workrate, but let's focus on execution) became the pedestal to reach, the pillar to aspire to. Everyone is somehow the Russian Judge holding up a 4.5* sign during the Olympic floor exercise.
But execution is a means, not an end. It's not supposed to make things look real. It's supposed to make things immersive. It's supposed to draw you in. It's supposed to make suspension of disbelief easier. It's supposed to take your heart and drive it into your stomach. It's supposed to make you feel.
That is the end. The end matters far more than the means. The end has always mattered far more than the means. Except for these discussions. Except for when workrate and execution and polish get invoked. Except for that tax shows up. Then suddenly people miss the forest for the trees.
Suspension of disbelief. Getting drawn in. Buying into what you're watching, not as "real," but as worth engaging with, worth giving yourself over to.
Maybe Marina Shafir is not conventionally "polished." Maybe she hits a kick on the outside and falls. Maybe her 619 driver takes an extra second to lock in. Maybe there are a half dozen examples of things not hitting quite clean or looking clunky.
But are you going to watch this match and tell me that you don't BELIEVE Marina Shafir?
Are you going to watch this match and tell me that you don't find her credible in all the ways that matter to help you let go and buy in, that you don't find her wrestling engaging? That you weren't drawn in by the story of this match?
Are you going to tell me that you got taken out during minute 11 because something felt a little rough around the edges and they lost you for the rest of the match?
That she lacked polish?
It's not about being robotically perfect. It's not even about being real. It's about being true.
And she is true.
This was true.
It was truth kicking you, barefoot, right in the face and making you feel something.
I think I saw more people upset about the outcome of this match than I've seen for a single match in ages.
And while that was partially due to Merecedes' time-tested preparation and precision, sure, so much of it was due to the raw and earnest emotion of Marina Shafir and how that intersected with her obvious and undeniable credibility and dedication. Her living, breathing truth.
After two years of being an imposing, immovable force on the outside, and a unyielding, trash-talking presence in the ring, she wore her heart on her sleeve, carried the weight of her inspirations, and put it all out there on the mat. That was the Mariko Yoshida gear and that was the drive for the Brutalizer, and it was so much in-between.
The story of the match was that Mercedes took Marina serious, deathly serious, that Mercedes was a pro and while she couldn't out wrestle Marina, she could have a solution for as many problems as possible. Sometimes that was quickly shifting approaches. Sometimes that was leaning on a more lucha-based style to stymie her. Sometimes it was throwing in a cheapshot. Sometimes it was disengaging. And even then, Marina kept coming, kept taking her over, kept owning wrist control. Mercedes could buy herself time and mitigate the damage but she would have gotten swept under eventually.
Those takeovers? They felt like a struggle. They were ugly. But they kept coming and they were inevitable. Marina was going to take Mercedes over and there was nothing she could do about it.
So at the first opening she could create, it was about putting the full force of her opportunistic assault into dismantling Marina's arm. All part of the plan, and against a wrestler like Marina, a wrestler like Mercedes absolutely needed a plan.
Marina honed in on the arm, the great equalizer. A match like this needed one. Marina fought from underneath, jamming holds, absorbing damage. Showing defiance. She blocked a cross arm breaker and when Mercedes turned it into a short arm scissors, she was able to reverse her way out.
Mercedes, frustrated, tried mind games, tried striking, and Marina met the moment in her own personal way. She slammed her head into the turnbuckle like Gabe Kidd. She danced like Daniel Garcia. She smacked Mercedes and dove right in. When Mercedes turned it around and tried for her a literal dive of her own, Marina caught her and locked in Mother's Milk on the floor. But Mercedes was Mercedes, always poised, always ready, and when Marina tried to (again literally) slap it on in the ring, she was able to slip under and get a nearfall out of it.
But Marina hefted her up, headbutted her down, and channeled Claudio for the swing. She followed that with the area code driver and then that aforementioned kick to the gut on a Mercedes who was diving off the apron. Yes, that did send Marina sprawling as well. Once upon a time, whether deserved or not, that sort of thing would have ended up in a botch compilation. Why? Because we as a community had fallen that far away from true north. Here, though, on this night? Fueled by Mercedes abandon and Marina's passion and drive?
Here, the fans started chanting "This is Awesome" for it. And why? Because it WAS awesome. Because something so undeniably true is awesome, and the fans could feel that truth in the air.
Marina followed it up by dropping Mercedes down like a sack of potatoes on the apron. And yeah, that was awesome too, because there was purpose and intent behind it, because it matched the moment and met the needs of the story and the match. Because of the ends it served.
They went back into the ring, in towards the finish. Marina went for the Death Rider.
And now it's past time to talk about that. In this, her first big babyface performance, in her biggest match ever, Marina carried those inspirations. They were deadly weapons against Mercedes. And maybe, probably, they were the reason why she couldn't beat Mercedes. I tend to be against tribute spots for their own sake, but this felt so much like Tanahashi vs Okada from the start of the year (feels like a million years ago now, doesn't it?), where Tanahashi was calling upon the weapons of his previous opponents and allies to offset a disadvantage against a superior opponent in Okada..
Here Marina had a disadvantage. Her arm was damaged. Mercedes had more experience. In some ways, she's just finding herself as a solo competitor and a babyface. She wasn't just paying tribute. She was using the weapons she trained with and against each and every day, leaning into successful tactics she had seen time and again at ringside. It made sense.
And it made sense that she would try to win with the Brutalizer, just like it made sense that Mercedes, a bully and egomaniac, would almost lose the match by trying to use it herself. In the end, Marina wanted it too badly. She locked it on but at too high a cost. They were near the ropes and Mercedes was able to roll over and use the rope to assist a pin and sneak away with the win and her belt.
Marina wrestled the match bolstered by her friends, her allies, her brothers, her partners in training and in battle. She carried the dual weights of grief and love and they empowered her and, at times, encumbered her.
To me, this match felt, as much as anything else, like a promise. As time marches on and Marina continues to train and strive and fight, the love will only strengthen and the grief will become more manageable, and she will grow more powerful and even more undeniable and she will triumph on her own terms and her own way. And the fans will be right there with her, because she's all of our problem now, and we're better off for it.
That brings us back to the start. Polish. Pro wrestling is the simulation of a fight, of a contest between warriors and athletes and practitioners and technicians. All too often, the narrative and visual language of pro wrestling makes everything so pretty and perfect, impeccably timed spots where everyone hits the landing. That's okay sometimes. It is.
But sometimes you want something rough around the edges, something dirty and nasty and brutal, something that feels raw and true. When there's tangible emotion behind it; when it owns what it is and marches forward with chin held high; when it's not just entertainment, but a primal scream that lunges down your through and shakes your spine; when the ends are clearly, wonderfully met even if the means wouldn't all pass the Russian Judges...
Well, that transcends such patronizing, demoralizing words such as polish. Six demeaning letters can't begin to contain the bursting energy of a match like this. And they can't begin to contain the emerging multitudes within Marina Shafir either.
Labels: 5 Fingers of Death, AEW, Full Gear, Marina Shafir, Mercedes Mone
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home